docs(arch): per-codebase ARCHITECTURE.md + cross-codebase overview

Strategic-depth architecture documentation, the kind that's hard to
recover by reading code: invariants, multi-file flows, design rationale,
gotchas. Goal is to cut the token cost for future Claude sessions.

Four new docs (2091 lines total):

- crates/relicario-core/ARCHITECTURE.md (514 lines) — bytes-in/bytes-out
  boundary, 24 verified invariants (VERSION_BYTE=0x02, length-prefixed
  KDF input, NFC normalization, content-addressed AttachmentId, history-
  tracked field kinds, 60% imgsecret confidence floor, MAX_DIMENSION=
  10000, etc.), 7 multi-module flows, 16 non-obvious gotchas (QUANT_STEP=
  50, central-70%-embed, BIP39-128bit-then-truncate, Steam alphabet
  rationale).

- crates/relicario-cli/ARCHITECTURE.md (539 lines) — module map for the
  three source files; the cmd_add/cmd_edit per-type helper pattern (post-
  2026-04-27 refactor); the hardened-git invariant (Command::new("git")
  is gated to helpers.rs:46); the five history synthetic keys; the env-
  var escape-hatch policy; cmd_generate's two-mode design (no-unlock
  outside vault, unlock-and-read-defaults inside).

- extension/ARCHITECTURE.md (831 lines) — five-bundle structure (popup,
  vault, setup, content, service-worker); SW-as-crypto-fortress model;
  capability-set-or-silent-rejection contract; vault-tab-as-popup-class
  router parity (commit a7dbf35); origin TOFU flow; setup state machine;
  test-vs-build gap.

- docs/architecture/overview.md (207 lines) — cross-codebase entry point.
  How the three codebases fit together, the four versioned wire formats
  between them (core→WASM ABI, SW chrome.runtime protocol, vault on-disk
  layout, GitHost API), per-codebase secret residency table, build
  matrix, conventions that span all three.

Specs in docs/superpowers/specs/ remain as historical decision artifacts
("why we chose this") — the new arch docs are the source of truth for
"what is" current invariants and flows.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
adlee-was-taken
2026-04-27 21:41:26 -04:00
parent b951741366
commit c66fd520f8
4 changed files with 2091 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,514 @@
# Architecture: relicario-core
## What this crate is for
`relicario-core` is the platform-agnostic cryptographic and data-model heart of the
relicario password manager. It is strictly **bytes-in / bytes-out**: every public
function takes byte slices or owned typed structs and returns byte vectors or typed
structs. The crate performs no filesystem I/O, no network I/O, no git operations,
and no time-of-day reads beyond `chrono::Utc::now()` for timestamping items
(`time.rs:6`). This boundary is what lets the same compiled artifact serve the
native CLI (`relicario-cli`), a `wasm32-unknown-unknown` build embedded in the
Chrome MV3 / Firefox WebExtension popup (`relicario-wasm`), and (eventually) ARM
mobile builds — without conditional compilation. Anything that touches a
`Path`, opens a socket, or shells out belongs in `relicario-cli` or the
extension layer, never here. The historical rationale is in
`docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-11-relicario-design.md` (sections "Crypto
Pipeline" and "Crate Layout").
## Module map
- **`lib.rs`** — Public API surface. Re-exports the symbols that callers actually
need (`encrypt_item`, `derive_master_key`, `Item`, `ItemCore`, etc.). The
module list here is the contract; everything else is internal.
- **`error.rs`** — `RelicarioError` (a `thiserror`-derived enum) plus the crate
alias `Result<T> = std::result::Result<T, RelicarioError>`. One error type
for the whole crate so FFI / WASM bindings and CLI handlers each have a single
exhaustive `match` to maintain. `Decrypt` is intentionally opaque (no inner
detail string) — see "Cross-cutting concerns".
- **`crypto.rs`** — KDF (`derive_master_key`, Argon2id with NFC-normalized,
length-prefixed inputs) and AEAD (`encrypt`, `decrypt`, XChaCha20-Poly1305
with `VERSION_BYTE = 0x02`). Owns the on-disk ciphertext layout. The KDF
parameters (`KdfParams`) are an owned struct that callers persist however
they like (CLI puts them in `.relicario/params.json`); the crate has no
opinion about storage.
- **`ids.rs`** — `ItemId`, `FieldId` (random 64-bit hex from `OsRng`,
`ids.rs:26-32`, `ids.rs:38-49`) and content-addressed `AttachmentId`
(first 8 bytes of `SHA-256(plaintext)`, `ids.rs:51-57`). Three separate
newtypes rather than `String` so misuses can't compile.
- **`time.rs`** — `now_unix()` and `MonthYear` (the validated 1..=12 / 2000..=2099
card-expiry type). Trivially small; broken out only because every other module
needs `now_unix()` and `MonthYear` is used by both `item.rs` and
`item_types/card.rs`.
- **`item_types/mod.rs`** — `ItemType` enum (snake-case wire tag) and `ItemCore`
(internally tagged `#[serde(tag = "type")]` enum), with one variant per item
type. The "extension via match exhaustiveness" pattern is documented at
`item_types/mod.rs:1-7`: adding an item type is a `cargo check` walk through
every match arm. Re-exports each per-type core.
- **`item_types/login.rs`** — `LoginCore` (username, password as
`Zeroizing<String>`, optional `Url`, optional `TotpConfig`).
- **`item_types/secure_note.rs`** — `SecureNoteCore` (single `Zeroizing<String>`
body).
- **`item_types/identity.rs`** — `IdentityCore` (full name, address, phone,
email, DOB; all optional, none `Zeroizing` — they're personal data, not
secret material).
- **`item_types/card.rs`** — `CardCore` plus `CardKind` (Credit/Debit/Gift/
Loyalty/Other). `number`, `cvv`, `pin` are `Zeroizing`; `holder` is plain
`String`.
- **`item_types/key.rs`** — `KeyCore`: opaque `Zeroizing<String>` `key_material`
with optional label / public key / algorithm. Used for SSH keys, GPG keys,
arbitrary blobs.
- **`item_types/document.rs`** — `DocumentCore`: filename + mime + a single
`AttachmentId` pointing at the primary blob. The body lives in the
attachment store, not the item.
- **`item_types/totp.rs`** — `TotpCore`, `TotpConfig`, `TotpAlgorithm`
(Sha1/Sha256/Sha512), `TotpKind` (Totp / Hotp{counter} / Steam), and the
`compute_totp_code()` function. Includes the Steam Mobile Authenticator
5-character alphabet and its conversion (`item_types/totp.rs:103-110`).
The same `TotpConfig` is reused as a sub-struct of `LoginCore` (so a Login
item can carry its own TOTP without spawning a separate item).
- **`item.rs`** — The `Item` envelope. Holds the parallel `FieldKind` /
`FieldValue` enums (kept parallel so callers can ask the kind without
inspecting the value, `item.rs:1-6`), `Field`, `Section`, `FieldHistoryEntry`,
and the `Item` struct itself with its `set_field_value` / `soft_delete` /
`restore` / `prune_history` mutators. Custom-fields and field-history live
here, not in the per-type cores.
- **`attachment.rs`** — `AttachmentRef` (full record carried on `Item`),
`AttachmentSummary` (compact form carried in `Manifest`),
`EncryptedAttachment`, and the `encrypt_attachment` / `decrypt_attachment`
helpers. The size cap is enforced **before** any crypto work (`attachment.rs:69-74`).
- **`manifest.rs`** — The browse-without-decrypt index: `Manifest`,
`ManifestEntry`, `MANIFEST_SCHEMA_VERSION = 2`. `upsert(&item)` rebuilds the
entry from the item — there is no path for the manifest to drift from the
source-of-truth item file. Includes case-insensitive title/tag search
(`manifest.rs:59-68`) and Login icon-hint derivation (host of the URL,
`manifest.rs:93-99`).
- **`settings.rs`** — `VaultSettings` and its sub-types: `TrashRetention`,
`HistoryRetention`, `GeneratorRequest` (`Random` or `Bip39`),
`AttachmentCaps`, plus the `autofill_origin_acks` map for the extension's
TOFU prompt.
- **`generators.rs`** — Random-password and BIP-39 passphrase generation, both
driven by `GeneratorRequest` from `settings.rs`. zxcvbn-backed
`rate_passphrase` and the `validate_passphrase_strength` gate that rejects
any score < 3.
- **`vault.rs`** — Typed wrappers around `crypto::{encrypt, decrypt}`:
`encrypt_item`/`decrypt_item`, `encrypt_manifest`/`decrypt_manifest`,
`encrypt_settings`/`decrypt_settings`. Each does
`serde_json::to_vec → encrypt` (or the inverse). The plaintext `Vec<u8>` is
wrapped in `Zeroizing` between serde and the cipher
(`vault.rs:18-19`, `vault.rs:24-26`).
- **`imgsecret.rs`** — Self-contained DCT-based steganography for the second
auth factor. Owns its own `YChannel`, `EmbedRegion`, 8×8 DCT/IDCT,
Quantization Index Modulation, and crop-recovery extractor. No other module
imports it; it is consumed only via the public re-export from `lib.rs`.
## Invariants & contracts
- **No filesystem, no network, no git, no spawn.** Verified by inspecting
imports; the only I/O-shaped types in use are in-memory `Cursor<&[u8]>`
for image decoding (`imgsecret.rs:243`).
- **No `unsafe`.** Confirmed by `grep` over `src/`. The crate compiles to WASM
unmodified for that reason.
- **No `async`.** All operations are pure compute on byte slices. Async lives
in `relicario-cli` (process spawning) and in the extension's service worker
(message channels), not here.
- **`VERSION_BYTE = 0x02`** (`crypto.rs:59`). Every blob produced by
`encrypt()` starts with this byte; `decrypt()` rejects any other value with
`RelicarioError::UnsupportedFormatVersion { found, expected }`
(`crypto.rs:127-132`). v1 blobs (the pre-rewrite format) are explicitly
tested for rejection (`tests/format_v2.rs:28-42`).
- **AEAD blob layout** is fixed at `version(1) || nonce(24) || ciphertext+tag(≥16)`
(`crypto.rs:18-32`). Minimum valid blob length is 41 bytes
(`crypto.rs:118-124`).
- **Nonces are always fresh from `OsRng`** (`crypto.rs:87-89`). There is no
caller-supplied nonce path. With 192 bits of randomness, collision risk is
negligible across the lifetime of any vault.
- **`MANIFEST_SCHEMA_VERSION = 2`** (`manifest.rs:12`). v1 manifests (which
predate typed items) are not handled here and are rejected at the JSON-parse
step.
- **KDF input is length-prefixed.** `derive_master_key` builds the password
buffer as `u64_be(len(passphrase)) || passphrase || u64_be(32) || image_secret`
(`crypto.rs:229-236`). This eliminates the (`"abc"`, `0x44…`) vs (`"abcD"`,
`…`) collision, and is exercised in
`crypto.rs:352-368` and `tests/format_v2.rs:44-54`.
- **Passphrases are NFC-normalized before hashing.** Bytes that aren't valid
UTF-8 pass through unchanged (`crypto.rs:223-227`). This keeps "café"
(precomposed) and "café" (combining acute) from producing different keys
(`crypto.rs:370-385`).
- **Master key only ever lives in `Zeroizing<[u8; 32]>`.** Returned that way
by `derive_master_key` (`crypto.rs:212`) and accepted that way by
`encrypt_item` / `encrypt_attachment` / friends. No public function in
`vault.rs` or `attachment.rs` accepts a raw `[u8; 32]`.
- **Plaintext is wrapped in `Zeroizing` between serde and the cipher.** See
`vault.rs:18-19`, `vault.rs:24-26`, `vault.rs:31-32`, `vault.rs:37-38`,
`vault.rs:44-45`, `vault.rs:50-51`. The serde JSON intermediate buffer is the
most exposed point, so it is wiped on drop.
- **`AttachmentId` is content-addressed** to the first 8 bytes (= 16 hex chars)
of `SHA-256(plaintext)` (`ids.rs:51-57`). Identical plaintexts deduplicate
in git automatically — proven in `tests/attachments.rs:28-35`. The 64-bit
prefix is used (rather than the full digest) to keep filenames short; the
collision space is still adequate for the expected vault size.
- **`ItemId` and `FieldId` are 16 hex chars** = 64 bits of `OsRng` entropy
(`ids.rs:25-32`, `ids.rs:38-49`). The audit (M8) bumped them from the
original 8-char / 32-bit format.
- **Field kind/value discriminants must agree.** `Field::new` derives `kind`
from `value` (`item.rs:85-94`); `Field::validate` (called after deserialize)
rejects any mismatch (`item.rs:97-107`). `set_field_value` further refuses
to change a field's kind (`item.rs:184-189`).
- **Field-history capture is restricted to three kinds:** `Password`,
`Concealed`, `Totp` (`item.rs:68-71`). Any other kind's update silently
skips history. The TOTP secret is base32-encoded for the history entry
(`item.rs:245-249`) so a user reading their history sees a recognizable
string.
- **History captures the *previous* value, not the new one** (`item.rs:190-197`):
`set_field_value` serializes `field.value` *before* assigning the new value.
- **`hidden_by_default` is set automatically** when the field's kind is
`Password` or `Concealed` (`item.rs:92`). The extension and CLI both honor
this hint when rendering.
- **Attachment cap is checked before encryption** (`attachment.rs:69-74`).
An oversize blob fails with `RelicarioError::AttachmentTooLarge { size, max }`
without ever calling `encrypt`. The CLI/extension are expected to read the
cap from `VaultSettings::attachment_caps`.
- **`Item::soft_delete` does not erase data.** It sets `trashed_at` and bumps
`modified` (`item.rs:205-208`). Purging is the caller's responsibility,
driven by `TrashRetention::should_purge` (`settings.rs:38-44`).
- **`prune_history` is idempotent and explicit.** Items keep all history until
the caller invokes it with a `HistoryRetention` policy (`item.rs:219-237`).
Last-N drops oldest first; Days drops anything older than `now - days·86400`.
- **`item_type()` is the single source of truth** for the type tag stored on
`Item`. `Item::new` derives `r#type` from the supplied `ItemCore`
(`item.rs:159-164`). Manual construction can violate this — the JSON
round-trip does not re-validate beyond serde's tag matching.
- **Reserved serde key:** no `*Core` may have a JSON-serialized field named
`"type"` — that name is reserved for serde's discriminator on `ItemCore`
(`item_types/mod.rs:38-40`). Use `"kind"` instead (see `CardKind`,
`TotpKind`).
- **`MAX_DIMENSION = 10_000`** for imgsecret (`imgsecret.rs:71`). Enforced via
a header-only peek (`imgsecret.rs:127-176`) at the entry of both `embed` and
`extract` so an attacker-supplied 32000×32000 JPEG is rejected without
decoding pixels (audit M3).
- **`MIN_DIMENSION = 100`** plus a "must hold ≥5 redundant copies" floor
(`imgsecret.rs:66`, `imgsecret.rs:78`, `imgsecret.rs:682-689`). Smaller
carriers are rejected with `ImageTooSmall`.
- **Strength gate is `score >= 3`** (`generators.rs:124-130`). Vault-creation
callers must invoke `validate_passphrase_strength` themselves; the crate
does not internally call it inside `derive_master_key` (since that path is
also used to derive the key for *unlock*, not just create).
- **`SymbolCharset::Custom` must be ASCII-only** (`generators.rs:46-52`).
Non-ASCII custom charsets are rejected with `RelicarioError::Format`.
## Key flows
### Vault unlock — key derivation
1. Caller obtains `passphrase: &[u8]` (UTF-8) and `image_secret: &[u8; 32]`
(typically from `imgsecret::extract` over the user's reference JPEG).
2. Caller loads `salt: [u8; 32]` and `KdfParams` from out-of-band storage
(CLI: `.relicario/salt` and `.relicario/params.json`).
3. `derive_master_key(passphrase, &image_secret, &salt, &params)`
`crypto.rs:207-244`:
- NFC-normalize the passphrase if it parses as UTF-8 (`crypto.rs:223-227`).
- Build the length-prefixed password buffer in a `Zeroizing<Vec<u8>>`
(`crypto.rs:229-236`).
- Run `Argon2id` with `Algorithm::Argon2id`, `Version::V0x13`,
output length 32 (`crypto.rs:213-221`, `crypto.rs:238-241`).
4. Returns `Zeroizing<[u8; 32]>` — automatically wiped on drop.
A wrong passphrase or wrong image produces a *different* derived key. The crate
cannot tell them apart at this stage; the caller learns "wrong factor" only
when subsequent `decrypt_*` returns `RelicarioError::Decrypt`.
### Item write
1. Caller mutates an `Item` (e.g. `item.set_field_value(&fid, new_value)`
`item.rs:181-203`). `set_field_value` captures previous value into
`field_history` if the kind is history-tracked, then bumps `modified`.
2. Caller calls `encrypt_item(&item, &master_key)``vault.rs:16-20`:
`serde_json::to_vec(item)` → wrap in `Zeroizing``crypto::encrypt`.
3. Caller calls `manifest.upsert(&item)` (`manifest.rs:45-48`) to refresh the
browse-index entry; then `encrypt_manifest(&manifest, &master_key)`
(`vault.rs:29-33`).
4. The two ciphertext blobs are returned to the caller, who writes them to disk
(or commits them, or sends them over a sync channel).
### Item read (browse-without-decrypt path)
1. Caller calls `decrypt_manifest(&manifest_blob, &master_key)`
(`vault.rs:35-40`). One AEAD decryption gets the entire searchable index.
2. `Manifest::search(query)` does a case-insensitive substring match over title
and tags (`manifest.rs:59-68`). `manifest.items.values()` gives every
`ManifestEntry` with `title`, `tags`, `favorite`, `group`, `icon_hint`,
`modified`, `trashed_at`, and `attachment_summaries` — enough to render a
list UI without touching any item file.
3. When the user picks an entry, the caller reads `entries/<id>.enc` and calls
`decrypt_item(&blob, &master_key)` (`vault.rs:22-27`) to get the full
`Item` including secret fields and `field_history`.
### Attachment encryption
1. Caller has `plaintext: &[u8]`, the `master_key`, and the active
`VaultSettings::attachment_caps.per_attachment_max_bytes`.
2. `encrypt_attachment(plaintext, &master_key, max_bytes)`
`attachment.rs:64-78`:
- If `plaintext.len() > max_bytes`, return `AttachmentTooLarge` *immediately*
before any crypto.
- `AttachmentId::from_plaintext(plaintext)` (SHA-256, `ids.rs:51-57`).
- `crypto::encrypt(master_key, plaintext)`.
3. Returns `EncryptedAttachment { id, bytes }`. The caller persists `bytes` at
`attachments/<id>.enc` and adds an `AttachmentRef { id, filename, mime_type,
size, created }` (`attachment.rs:11-20`) to the owning `Item`. On
`Manifest::upsert`, an `AttachmentSummary` (no `created` field) is derived
automatically (`manifest.rs:87`).
### Field-history capture
1. Triggered exclusively by `Item::set_field_value` (`item.rs:181-203`). Direct
mutation of `field.value` bypasses history — the type system does not
prevent this.
2. The check `field.value.is_history_tracked()` runs *on the existing value*
(`item.rs:190`), so adding the *first* password value to a previously-empty
field does not create a history entry; updating an already-set password
does.
3. The previous value is serialized via `serialize_history_value`
(`item.rs:241-253`):
- `Password(p)` and `Concealed(c)` clone the inner string into a fresh
`Zeroizing<String>`.
- `Totp(cfg)` base32-encodes the raw secret bytes
(`item.rs:245-249`, `item.rs:256-275`).
- Any other kind would error (`item.rs:250`), but is unreachable because
`is_history_tracked` already gated the call.
4. Pruning is *not* automatic. Callers (CLI commit hook, extension save handler)
call `item.prune_history(&settings.field_history_retention, now_unix())`
when they want to enforce the policy.
### imgsecret embed
1. Caller passes a JPEG byte slice and a 32-byte secret to
`imgsecret::embed(carrier_jpeg, &secret)` (`imgsecret.rs:666-726`).
2. `enforce_dimension_cap` walks JPEG markers (`imgsecret.rs:127-161`) to read
the SOF dimensions; rejects > 10_000 × 10_000 before any pixel decode.
3. `extract_y_channel` decodes via `image::ImageReader` and converts each pixel
to BT.601 luminance (`imgsecret.rs:242-265`).
4. `central_region` picks the inner 70% of the image as the embed region; the
15% margin per side is the "crumple zone" for crops
(`imgsecret.rs:268-293`).
5. `compute_embed_positions` / `select_embed_blocks` lay out
`num_copies × BLOCKS_PER_COPY` 8×8 blocks evenly across the region, with
`num_copies` = `min(50, total_blocks / 22)` (`imgsecret.rs:530-575`).
6. For each block: 2D DCT (`dct2_8x8`, `imgsecret.rs:393-412`) → embed 12 bits
into the 12 mid-frequency coefficients listed in `EMBED_POSITIONS`
(zig-zag positions 617, `imgsecret.rs:105-118`) via QIM with
`QUANT_STEP = 50.0` (`imgsecret.rs:462-467`) → 2D inverse DCT → write
back into Y.
7. `reconstruct_jpeg` (`imgsecret.rs:590-640`) re-derives Cb/Cr per pixel from
the original RGB (so chrominance is preserved), combines with the modified
Y, and re-encodes at JPEG quality 92.
### imgsecret extract (with crop recovery)
1. `extract(jpeg_bytes)` enforces the dimension cap, then delegates to
`extract_with_crop_recovery` (`imgsecret.rs:738-741`,
`imgsecret.rs:849-899`).
2. **Try 1** — assume uncropped: `try_extract_with_layout(&y, w, h, 0, 0)`.
This is the hot path; for a freshly embedded image it always succeeds.
3. **Try 2** — width-only crop, block-aligned: iterate `orig_w` from current
width up to `1.20 × current_w` in 8-px steps, with `dx = 0`
(assume right-edge crop).
4. **Try 3** — height-only crop, block-aligned: same strategy on the vertical
axis.
5. **Try 4** — width crops at non-block-aligned 1-px steps, skipping any
already covered in Try 2.
6. `try_extract_with_layout` (`imgsecret.rs:754-834`) tallies QIM votes for
each of the 256 bit positions across all `num_copies` copies. Each bit
must reach **≥60% confidence** (`imgsecret.rs:824`); below that, the
whole extraction fails with `ExtractionFailed` (no partial result is
ever returned).
7. The 60% threshold is per-bit, not aggregate — a single unconfident bit
aborts the whole try. This makes false-positive extractions from
never-embedded images vanishingly unlikely.
## Cross-cutting concerns
- **Error model.** `RelicarioError` (`error.rs:15-89`) is a single
`thiserror`-derived enum. `Decrypt` is the deliberately-opaque "wrong key
or tampered ciphertext" variant (audit M4 — `error.rs:28-30`,
`tests/integration.rs:99-111`): the message is just `"decryption failed"`
with no inner string, and it does not distinguish wrong-passphrase from
wrong-image-secret from corrupted ciphertext. `Format` is the
"input bytes don't make sense" variant (e.g. blob too short, schema
mismatch). `UnsupportedFormatVersion` is the structured "wrong version
byte" variant — separate from `Format` because callers want to react to
it differently (offer migration, etc.).
- **Where secrets live.** Every secret type wraps `Zeroizing<...>`:
- The derived master key: `Zeroizing<[u8; 32]>` (`crypto.rs:212`).
- Field values: `FieldValue::Password(Zeroizing<String>)` and
`FieldValue::Concealed(Zeroizing<String>)` (`item.rs:39-40`).
- `FieldHistoryEntry::value`: `Zeroizing<String>` (`item.rs:127`).
- Per-type cores: `LoginCore::password`, `CardCore::{number,cvv,pin}`,
`KeyCore::key_material`, `SecureNoteCore::body`, `TotpConfig::secret`
(a `Zeroizing<Vec<u8>>` of the raw HMAC key).
- Decrypted attachment plaintext: `Zeroizing<Vec<u8>>`
(`attachment.rs:88-92`).
- Argon2id input buffer (`crypto.rs:232`) and JSON serialization buffers in
`vault.rs` are wrapped in `Zeroizing` to wipe the intermediate plaintext.
- **Format versioning.** Three independent version channels exist, each
gating something different:
- `crypto::VERSION_BYTE = 0x02` (`crypto.rs:59`) — gates the AEAD blob
layout. Bumped if the nonce length, header layout, or cipher changes.
A v1 blob is rejected with a typed
`UnsupportedFormatVersion { found: 0x01, expected: 0x02 }`.
- `manifest::MANIFEST_SCHEMA_VERSION = 2` (`manifest.rs:12`) — gates the
JSON-level shape of the manifest. v1 manifests had a different layout
and would fail to parse against the current `Manifest` struct.
- The `.relbak` import/export format defined in
`docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-27-relicario-import-export-design.md`
will introduce a third version channel for backups; that surface lives
outside this crate.
- **KDF parameter handling.** `KdfParams` (`crypto.rs:156-168`) is just a
serializable struct. The crate has no opinion about where it is stored,
how it is rotated, or who increments it. `Default` gives the production
values (`m=65536`, `t=3`, `p=4``crypto.rs:175-183`) calibrated for
~0.51 s on a modern desktop. Tests universally use the fast triplet
`(m=256, t=1, p=1)` defined as a `fn fast_params()` near the top of every
test file.
- **NFC normalization is the only Unicode op.** All passphrase canonicalization
happens in one place (`crypto.rs:223-227`). Item titles, field labels,
tags, etc. are stored verbatim — only the passphrase fed to the KDF is
normalized.
- **No per-entry subkeys.** Every encrypted blob (item, manifest, settings,
attachment) is encrypted with the *same* master key. The design rationale
is in `docs/superpowers/specs/2026-04-11-relicario-design.md` lines 66:
per-entry subkey derivation would add complexity for no real-world benefit
given the expected family-vault size.
- **CSPRNG is `OsRng` everywhere.** `ItemId::new`, `FieldId::new`,
`derive_master_key` (no-op — the salt is caller-supplied),
`crypto::encrypt` (nonce), `generators::random_password`,
`generators::bip39_passphrase`. A single `rand::thread_rng()` call exists
inside an `imgsecret` test (`imgsecret.rs:1033`) to generate a random test
secret; production code is `OsRng` only.
- **`ed25519-dalek` is a dependency placeholder.** Listed in
`Cargo.toml:17` but unused in `src/`. It exists for the future
device-key surface (`RelicarioError::DeviceKey` is the reserved variant,
`error.rs:84-88`); device-key signing currently happens in
`relicario-cli` instead.
## Test architecture
All `tests/` files use the fast Argon2id triplet `m=256, t=1, p=1` so the
suite runs in seconds, not minutes. Test JPEGs are synthesized at runtime via
`make_test_jpeg(width, height)` (`imgsecret.rs:908-924`) — a deterministic RGB
pattern at quality 92 — so no binary fixtures live in git.
- **`tests/integration.rs`** — End-to-end vault workflows: encrypt+decrypt a
Login and a SecureNote through `Manifest`/`VaultSettings`, two-factor
independence (different passphrase or different image_secret yields
different keys), field-history surviving an encrypt/decrypt round-trip,
and the wrong-key-→-`Decrypt` opaqueness contract.
- **`tests/attachments.rs`** — Round-trip a 5 KB blob, prove identical
plaintexts produce identical `AttachmentId`s (despite different ciphertext
bytes due to fresh nonces), and exercise the cap boundary at exactly the
max byte and one over.
- **`tests/field_history.rs`** — Sequential `set_field_value` calls accumulate
history in oldest→newest order; `prune_history(LastN(3))` keeps the most
recent 3; field-history survives `encrypt_item``decrypt_item`.
- **`tests/format_v2.rs`** — `VERSION_BYTE == 0x02`, fresh ciphertext starts
with `0x02`, a v1-shaped blob (`[0x01][24 nonce][16 tag]`) is rejected with
the typed `UnsupportedFormatVersion`, and the length-prefix construction
prevents `("abc", 0x44…)` / `("abcD", …)` collisions.
- **`tests/generators.rs`** — Aggregates 80 × 128 = 10,240 chars from
`generate_password` to assert per-character-class proportions are within
±5 pp of the expected uniform distribution; verifies that 5-word BIP-39
passes the strength gate while common weak passwords ("password",
"12345678", "letmein", "qwertyui", "hunter2") all fail; asserts uniqueness
across 1000 default-config calls. The opening doc comment
(`tests/generators.rs:1-13`) explains why the original "10,000-char single
call" plan switched to aggregation: `generate_password` enforces
`length ≤ 128`.
In-module `#[cfg(test)] mod tests` blocks cover unit-level invariants (kind/
value mismatches, snake-case serde tags, base32 round-trips, `MonthYear`
constructor bounds, the Steam alphabet ambiguity audit). The `imgsecret`
test block additionally proves DCT round-tripping, QIM noise tolerance below
`Q/4 = 12.5`, embed→Q85-recompress→extract round-trip, embed→10%-crop→extract
round-trip, and the oversized-image-header rejection path.
## Gotchas & non-obvious decisions
- **`QUANT_STEP = 50.0` is intentionally double the academic value of 25**
(`imgsecret.rs:62`). Higher quantization steps make the watermark more robust
to JPEG recompression at Q85 and below — at the cost of more visible
artifacts in the carrier. The reference image is a personal photo, not a
publication, so the trade-off favors robustness.
- **The embed region is the *central 70%* (15% margin per side, "crumple
zone")** — `imgsecret.rs:212-218`, `imgsecret.rs:276-293`. Anything in the
outer 15% is sacrificed so that mild edge crops (e.g. social-media platform
trims) leave the embedded data intact. Tested up to 10% crop in
`imgsecret.rs:1108-1137`.
- **Per-bit majority voting with a 60% confidence floor.**
`try_extract_with_layout` tallies votes from every redundant copy and
fails the entire extraction if any single bit position is below 60%
agreement (`imgsecret.rs:824`). This is more conservative than a global
threshold and is what makes false positives from never-embedded images
essentially zero — see `extract_from_non_embedded_image_fails`
(`imgsecret.rs:1041-1045`).
- **Number of redundant copies is capped at 50** (`imgsecret.rs:536`,
`imgsecret.rs:692-693`). Beyond that, per-block visual artifacts compound
faster than the error-correction benefit grows.
- **`peek_jpeg_dimensions` walks JPEG markers manually instead of using the
`image` crate.** `imgsecret.rs:127-161`. A full `ImageReader::decode` of an
attacker-supplied 30 000 × 30 000 JPEG would allocate ~3.6 GB of pixel
buffer in the WASM service worker before failing — the manual walk reads
only the SOF segment and bails in O(marker-count) (audit M3).
- **`bip39` always generates 128 bits of entropy** (12 mnemonic words) and
truncates to `word_count` (`generators.rs:82-89`). This is because
`bip39 v2` rejects entropy below 128 bits, but we want to support 312 word
passphrases. Truncation preserves the per-word independence — the words
the user sees still come from a uniformly-sampled-then-truncated 12-word
draw.
- **Steam TOTP output is exactly 5 characters from a 26-glyph alphabet,
regardless of the `digits` field on `TotpConfig`** (`item_types/totp.rs:103-110`,
asserted in `item_types/totp.rs:240-253`). The alphabet
(`23456789BCDFGHJKMNPQRTVWXY`) excludes `0/O`, `1/I/L`, `S` (so `5` is
unambiguous), `A`, `E`, `U`, `Z` — all glyphs Valve considered ambiguous
in the Steam Mobile Authenticator. Verified at
`item_types/totp.rs:274-283`.
- **`ItemCore` is internally-tagged with `#[serde(tag = "type")]`** — the
outer JSON object gets a `"type"` key. This means *no* `*Core` struct may
have a field literally named `type`. The convention chosen for
type-discriminant fields *inside* a core is `kind` — see `CardKind`,
`TotpKind` (`item_types/mod.rs:38-40`).
- **The TOTP base32 in field-history strips padding.** `base32_encode`
(`item.rs:256-275`) is RFC-4648 with no `=` padding — appropriate because
the value is for human display in history, not for re-decoding.
- **`AttachmentId::from_plaintext` uses only the first 8 bytes (= 16 hex
chars) of the SHA-256 digest** (`ids.rs:51-57`). 64 bits of collision
resistance is sufficient for a personal-vault attachment count; it keeps
filenames short. If a future use case demands collision resistance against
motivated adversaries (e.g. dedup across untrusted vaults), this width is
the lever.
- **`Field::new` derives `kind` from `value`, but the public struct still
stores both** (`item.rs:73-94`). The duplication exists so callers can
match on `kind` without inspecting (and potentially decrypting / cloning)
`value`. `validate()` is the safety net that runs after deserialization.
- **`set_field_value` refuses to change a field's kind** (`item.rs:184-189`).
The intent is that fields are conceptually fixed-shape after creation;
changing a `Text` to a `Password` should be done by deleting the old field
and creating a new one (so history doesn't get confused).
- **`hidden_by_default` is *not* `Zeroize`.** It's purely a UI hint — the
rendering layer (CLI output, popup card) decides whether to mask the value
on initial display. Secrecy at rest is enforced by the `Zeroizing` wrappers
on the value itself, not this flag.
- **`Manifest::upsert` rebuilds the entry from scratch every call**
(`manifest.rs:45-48`, `manifest.rs:75-89`). There is no "patch the
existing entry" path. This means the manifest can never carry a stale
`icon_hint` or `attachment_summaries` — they are derived freshly from the
source `Item` each time.
- **The strength gate is *not* called inside `derive_master_key`.** It must
be invoked separately by the caller during *vault creation* only — not
during unlock, where calling it would let an attacker probe whether a
wrong passphrase happens to be "strong enough" before the Argon2id work
even starts. See `generators.rs:124-130`.
- **`now_unix()` is `chrono::Utc::now().timestamp()` and is the single time
source in this crate** (`time.rs:6-8`). Tests that need determinism pass an
explicit `now: i64` to `prune_history` (`item.rs:219`) and similar — they
do not stub `now_unix`.